Staff Contributors
Guest Contributors

Edible Media: Anti-local yokel

Joel Stein of Time takes a poke at the locavores

Posted by Tom Philpott at 3:32 PM on 15 Jan 2008

The contrarian in me grinned when I read the concept. Time columnist Joel Stein pulls an anti-Pollan: He will cook dinner using only ingredients that traveled at least 3,000 miles from his home in L.A.

And -- deliciously -- he will do his shopping at Whole Foods, which he declares "the local-food movement's most treasured supermarket, the one that has huge locally grown signs next to the fruits and vegetables."

Ha, ha. It is a pretty funny joke -- especially on those in the local-food movement who treasure Whole Foods (a miniscule number, in my experience). But Stein's article brims with commonsense idiocies. Even though his piece is sure to inspire all manner of outrage throughout the locavore blogosphere -- precisely his goal, no doubt -- I'll add my voice as well.

The funniest line may have been unintentional: Sourcing his long-distance meal, it turned out, "was not an easy task. Farmers in Southern California, it seems, can grow anything."

Here Stein is unwittingly acknowledging a triumph of the local-food movement. Even 10 years ago, in most places throughout the U.S. where "farmers can grow anything," supermarkets including Whole Foods carried little in the way of local produce. Farmland tended to be dominated by monocrops; small and mid-sized diversified farms were under extreme pressure and lacked market access.

Today, in metro areas surrounded by ag-friendly land throughout the United States, things have gotten much better. Farmers markets and CSAs connected consumers with farmers, and farmers began to be rewarded for growing diverse crops with quality, not just yield, as the driving goal.

Eventually, supermarkets -- including, but not only, Whole Foods -- began trumpeting their devotion to local produce, and even buying from local farmers.

Of course, there are still significant problems. After 50 years of rapid consolidation and industrialization of the food system, huge infrastructural gaps limit the potential of local food systems. Canneries, slaughterhouses, milk-processing facilities, central storage and wholesaling spaces -- all used to be common features across the land, and all have become scarce as fewer and fewer corporations grab hold of more and more of the food system.

Largely because of this infrasructural gap, local food tends to be more expensive than factory fare -- making it in a sense a luxury for the well-off.

Yet tremendous progress has been made. How excellent that Stein had trouble finding nonlocal produce at his L.A. Whole Foods.

Stein's ignorance of this history leads him to a whopper. Making fun of politician Chris Dodd for praising the eat-local movement in Iowa, Stein lets loose with this bit:

Dodd was basically telling the Iowans that every night they should decide whether to accompany their pork with creamed corn, corn on the cob, corn fritters or corn bread. For dessert, they could have any flavor they wanted of fake ice cream made from soy, provided that flavor was corn.

Right, because all you can grow in Iowa is corn, soy, and pork. Ha, ha. But Iowa as corn/soy/pork factory is a pretty new concept.

Turns out that for most of its agricultural history, Iowa's rich topsoil produced all manner of delicious fruits and vegetables (PDF). And today, largely because of the same movement that transformed the produce section of Stein's Whole Foods, Iowa's agridiversity is coming back with a vengeance. You can get a terrific local meal in Iowa City -- and even Sioux City.

After taking his silly poke at Dodd, Stein gets around to reporting on his meal. Comparing himself (appropriately) to "some sort of insane European king," Stein recounts his shopping trip:

Marcona almonds from Spain that were so much softer, sweeter and nuttier than any I can get here; Greek olives; Brie from France; smoked salmon from Scotland. I thought about getting a rack of lamb from New Zealand, but I couldn't resist asking the guy behind the seafood counter for the fish with the most frequent-flyer miles. I was going to get the opah from Fiji, but then I spotted the Chilean sea bass from South Georgia island, southeast of Argentina -- more than 7,000 miles of travel just to get eaten for a magazine article ... I added some asparagus from Peru to my shopping cart and, for dessert, threw in a pineapple from Hawaii (which was cheating, it turned out, at just 2,500 miles, but it looked so good and my sense of geography is so bad) and a young coconut from Thailand.

The tone pretty much summarizes the trouble with the modern Western way of eating: all of these wondrous products appear before Stein as if by magic; he has no idea of the social/ecological context in which that "young coconut" grew; what it does to South Georgia and its citizens to satisfy his sea-bass habit, etc.

Nor does he care: his point is that he has access to these wondrous products, and should thus be able to enjoy them at will. Stein's likening himself to a king reminds me of a passage from Civilization and Its Discontents, Freud's meditation on human happiness and lack thereof. Writing in 1929 -- and still embittered by the insanity of World War I -- Freud considers recent technological breakthroughs:

All these assets he [modern man] may lay claim to as his cultural acquisition. Long ago he formed a conception of omnipotence and omniscience, which he embodied in his gods. To these gods he attributed everything that seemed unattainable to his wishes, or that was forbidden to him. One may say, therefore, that these gods were cultural ideals. Today he has come very close to the attainment of this ideal; he has almost become a god himself.

An almost-god in his kitchen, Stein lords over his ingredients and congratulates himself on his power to consume from all corners of the globe. Back to Freud:

Man has, as it were, become a kind of prosthetic God. When he puts on all of his auxiliary organs he is truly magnificent; but those organs have not grown on to him and they still give him much trouble at times.

Likewise, our food system, for all of its power to deliver us the world's bounty seemingly without effort, still gives us much trouble at times -- and is likely not done troubling us.

Stein also claims the local-food movement revels in "self-denial." An ironic charge, given that he willfully denied himself all of that wonderful Southern California produce.

Time for 'Locavores' to Shut Up and Eat

Thanks for bringing this asinine "experiment" to our attention. Too bad, since Stein could do some actual good with his column.

But then again, that's what the media does with any movement that they perceive as a fad. NPR started taking pokes at the local food movement in December: anyone hear this recent rant entitled "It's Time for 'Locavores' to Shut Up and Eat" ?

"The New Oxford American Dictionary chose "locavore" as its 2007 Word of the Year. Commentator Amy Stewart says it's time to change the subject and end the year of eating locally."

http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=1772 ...

The commentator makes some valid comments about how too much time at festive meals these days is directed at just how local the meal constituents are. Unfortunately, the bored commentator misses the subtext, that this is more than idle chat about ingredients: it's people discussing community.

Erik


The Orion Grassroots Network: supporting grassroots groups working for conservation, justice, & more

Nice response

Thank you so much for writing this post. The TIME article made my blood boil and I'm pleased to see a rational and thoughtful response here. I would have shoved my backyard-grown carrots down his throat :)

Time

The flagship of mass delusional media.  They had perfected misinformation while the NYT and WSJ were still doing it out of sheer ignorance and incompetence.

Are their any cannibals Stein could be shipped halfway around the world too?  Nice american fat marbled, fat head for dinner folks!

http://amazngdrx.blogharbor.com/blog John Schneider, Northern Wisconsin

Après nous le déluge

"My sense of geography is so bad," Stein admits.  Well, for starters that is OK.  But the full list of what he has a bad sense of goes on and on.

Chickens deserve our true friendship! So do fish! So do other sentient beings! Let us learn to be kind.
NPR Rant

You can view the response of the Eat Local Challenge authors to Amy Stewart's NPR rant over at the eatlocalchallenge.com site.

Ironically, Ms. Stewart published an article in the NYTimes about the importance of local flower shops. Seems a bit of a contradiction, huh?

The author of this long distance menu probably missed a much better meal closer to home. Oh well, his loss.

You are welcome in my "kitchen" for a recipe, family moments, a laugh, and some political discussion.

Actually, the author is Joel Stein

Just wanted to point out that the author's name is actually Joel Stein, and he's a long-time humor columnist for Time and others.

Thanks, ecopower

Error fixed.

Victual Reality
Carrot brigade

Ceolrince, I'm with you. And thanks to my clay soils, my homegrown Nantes are fat enough that they just might shut him up.

This is the sort of reporting that makes me glad I got out of journalism when I did. There's some afterlife waiting for Stein wherein he subsides on nothing but unleached acorns he gathered himself. Grrr....

Eat what you grow, grow what you eat

support local.

I would rather support my local farmers and community then to consumer goods that I am not sure of the conditions they were made in! The taste in locally grown food is also different. Example: veggies from farmers markets taste better then the ones in the super market that traveled thousands of miles.

Another benefit of eating locally is, it makes me try new and different things at different times in the year. Whereas shopping from the super market, I usually buy the usual stuff all the time!

Don't trash Joel Stein. He's on our side!

If you-all are serious when you bash Joel Stein, it's a shame because deep down, he wasn't bashing locavores. In fact, his essay is (I think) a tongue-in-cheek critique of people who indulge in long-distance dining without know the true consequences of such indulgence. And, Tom Philpott, I'm nearly certain Joel Stein knew what he was saying when he wrote, "Farmers in Southern California, it seems, can grow anything." He's well aware of the bounty to be had in one's backyard, and I imagine he appreciates that bounty. He's just tired of hearing earnest sermons on the virtues of local eating, and he decided to poke some fun. That's what he does, after all.

You are not logged in. Thus, you cannot post a comment. If you have an account, log in. If you don't have an account, well, by all means go make one! Meet you back here in five.
sign in
Search Gristmill
Subscribe
  • subscribe via RSSStay updated with the Gristmill RSS feed.
  • Add to My Yahoo!
  • Subscribe with Bloglines
  • Subscribe in NewsGator Online
  • Subscribe in Netvibes
  • Subscribe in Google
Using Gristmill
  • What is Gristmill?
  • Posting rules
The comments of Gristmill users reflect the opinions of those individuals only, and do not necessarily reflect the viewpoints of Grist, its staff, its board members, their psychotherapists, or their aestheticians. Got it?

Gristmill is powered by Scoop.

ADVERTISING POLICY


About Grist | Support Grist | Job Board | Archives | Grist by Email | RSS | Podcast
Gristmill Blog | In the News | Ask Umbra | Muckraker | Victual Reality | 'Tis the Season | The Grist List | The Bottom Line



Grist: Environmental News and Commentary
a beacon in the smog (tm) ©2008. Grist Magazine, Inc. All rights reserved. Gloom and doom with a sense of humor®.
Webmaster | Sitemap | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Trademarks