Staff Contributors
Guest Contributors

Meat Wagon: Factory farms milk the government

Conservation title schemes, youth flee CAFO country, and a side of E. coli beef

Posted by Tom Philpott at 11:42 PM on 14 Jan 2008

In Meat Wagon, we round up the latest outrages from the meat industry.

In the business section of Sunday's New York Times, reporter Andrew Martin shined a bright light on a USDA program called the Environmental Quality Incentives Program, or EQIP.

Funded through the conservation title of the farm bill, EQIP was originally intended to support farmers who wanted to improve the ecological performance of their farms -- say, by sharing the cost of building a fence to keep grazing cows from polluting a stream.

But in 2002 -- reported Aimee Witteman of the Sustainable Agriculture Coalition in a Gristmill post back in May -- EQIP funding became available to huge concentrated animal feedlot operations (CAFOs).

CAFO operators began to funnel EQIP cash into bolstering their massive, toxic manure lagoons -- lowering the cost of doing business for perhaps the most environmentally destructive form of agriculture known to man. Using taxpayer -- i.e., your -- cash.

Or as the Times' Martin puts it:

[Y]ou may be surprised to learn that your tax dollars have helped pave the way for the growth of these livestock megafarms by paying farmers to deal with the mountains of excrement that their farms generate. All of this is carried out under the rubric of "conservation." Congress is about to renew the program -- and possibly even expand it -- as part of a new farm bill wending its way through the Capitol.

EQIP has become a massive sop to the CAFO industry. Martin reports that in 2006 alone, the program paid out $179 million to CAFO operators, mostly in Iowa, Wisconsin, and North Carolina. "That compares with $125 million for soil erosion and sediment control, $139 million for irrigation water management and $74 million for grazing land practices," Martin adds.

Interestingly, Ken Cook of the Environmental Working Group -- a scathing critic of commodity subsidies -- offered a measured defense of EQIP, telling Martin that the program delivers benefits that outweigh its CAFO-supporting drawbacks.

But rather than defend EQIP, enviros would do better to promote the Conservation Security Program, another initiative contained in the farm bill's conservation title. The CSP supports real conservation efforts without offering sops to megafarms.

This debate will be coming to fore over the next few weeks as the House and Senate reconcile their 2007 farm bill versions. Martin reports that the Senate version would hold EQIP funding at current levels, while the House version unconscionably would jack up EQIP funding by slashing CSP funding.

Why are the kids fleeing Iowa?

Iowa produces more hogs -- and houses more CAFOs -- than any state in the nation. It's also evidently having trouble retaining talented young folks.

In an op-ed in Sunday's Des Moines Register, Brian DePew of the Rural Affairs Coalition reports:

In 2005, legislators floated a plan to exempt Iowans under 30 from state income taxes. Then last year, the Legislature commissioned "Generation Iowa" to ponder the problem [of youth flight] further.

DePew -- who himself grew up on an Iowa farm, and left the state after college -- wonders if the proliferation of giant, fetid animal factories might have something to do with the phenomenon. The number of CAFOs surged in Iowa in the 1990s, and their numbers continue growing today. Reports DePew:

I recently returned from a visit to my family's farm. While there, I was dismayed to learn that three more livestock confinement buildings are being built within 2 miles. Once complete, there will be 13 industrial livestock buildings within 3 miles of our farm. There is now at least one facility in every direction.

Given such realities, DePew writes, retaining youth in Iowa might require more than tweaking the tax code or forming committees. It might require imposing -- and enforcing -- serious regulations on a destructive industry. As CAFOs have expanded in size and number, family farms have abandoned the countryside, leaving behind hollowed-out towns and often environmentally devastated landscapes. Writes DePew:

With palpable air pollution and undeniable water pollution, the environmental strife is easy to see. With fewer family livestock producers, rural communities are left without a vital sector of economic activity. As farm families leave the countryside, rural communities face the challenge of keeping afloat critical social infrastructure such as schools and government services. No young Iowan wants to return to a dying community or a polluted state.

DePew notes that in the 2006 elections, Democrats captured all three branches of government for the first time in 40 years. They promised to rein in the CAFO industry, he reports, but "they largely capitulated on this issue." Sounds a bit like the national Democrats and Iraq.

Big Meat greets '08 with first E. coli recall

After a record-shattering year for recalls in 2007, the meat industry has started the New Year with a bang, issuing its first recall of the year. This one involved 188,000 pounds of hamburger meat possibly tainted with E. coli O157:H7 -- enough for approximately 750,000 Quarter Pounders.

The meat emerged from Minnesota; five people in Wisconsin, and one in California, have come up ill as a result.

Over on Ethicurean, they've taken to monitoring the recall situation with a color-coded risk alert. The current "Hamburger Threat Level" rates a code orange, or high. Easy on those Whoppers, folks.

CAFOs, flight, etc.

Re youth flight, you can't just single out CAFOs in Iowa, but see this as part of the whole industrialization process of agriculture in the  Midwest that has diminished the quality of life and undermined local communities.  

The mega CAFOs are particularly egregious.  But, I need to point out the problem with cattle and hog feeders that practice open livestock operations in close proximity to streams and rivers.  During heavy rain events these operations contribute heavily to the degradation of waterways.  I do not see much evidence that these operations are being monitored or regulated by any governmental agencies.  

I do not defend CAFOs but I can't help but wondering whether or not small CAFOs might not be more environmentally sound than the open operations that continue to heavily degrade woodlands, riparian habitat, and streams.    

Geographical Constraints

Not a lot of info on this in the northeast unfortunately.  If only the financial and political decisionmakers lived in the heartland instead of the mid-atlantic states.  I'm trying.

Dave
E. Coli

One of the major causes of E. Coli outbreaks in people is the way in which industrial farms unnaturally feed cows corn. When cows eat grass, the rumen (the organ that starts the digestive process) has a neutral pH. When they eat corn, the rumen becomes acidic. This helps to breed E. Coli bacteria that can survive the acid in human stomachs, thus making us ill and killing us. It's all a bit like how antibiotic use in factory farms promotes the development of antibiotic resistant bacteria.

Just feeding cows grass instead of corn during the last few days of their lives apparently reduces the number of E. Coli bacteria in their digestive tracts by 80% (though the previous time still helps breed acid resistant bugs). Unfortunately, most factory farms seem to prefer to try to deal with the problem through less effective means, helping the number of cases of E. Coli contamination to increase.

a sibilant intake of breath

I like this section- Good job Tom...

Any information that helps to expose the meat industry, the environmental scourge that it is, gets my vote every day of every week all year long....

We need to focus on the root causes of problems.
It's all connected

Unfortunately, many people don't realize that the factory farms and agribusiness are intimately connected. Iowa is becoming a state of mega-farms that produce only two things - corn and beef. They are big business. They are not producing food for consumption - at least 80% of the Iowa corn grown is fed to animals! - and I won't even mention the horrible conditions under which these animals (cows, pigs, etc.) live or how they are slaughtered daily. Driving through Orange County, NY, I have been assailed with the stench of concentrated manure from a nearby dairy farm. Who wants to live near that?

I response to my disgust over the turn our food supply has taken, I have gone vegan (to protect the environment, the animals, and my health), and I buy organic as much as possible. When people start going against nature the way we have with our factory farms and agribusinesses, we will certainly suffer the consequences.

"palpable air pollution"

Yuck!  What an image!

Nature Guru,
well done!  The more vegans the merrier!, says the Earth.

On the fecklessness of Iowa Democrats: Yes, that is pretty exasperating.

Are these the guys in office who are presumably supported by the pro-Obama caucusers?  Like, full of youth and energy and idealism?  Impelling a brilliant new movement of hope and joy? -- Gevalt.

JustLou,
I do not know where you are going with the idea about small CAFOs, but kindly count me out for now.

Chickens deserve our true friendship! So do fish! So do other sentient beings! Let us learn to be kind.

You are not logged in. Thus, you cannot post a comment. If you have an account, log in. If you don't have an account, well, by all means go make one! Meet you back here in five.
sign in
Search Gristmill
Subscribe
  • subscribe via RSSStay updated with the Gristmill RSS feed.
  • Add to My Yahoo!
  • Subscribe with Bloglines
  • Subscribe in NewsGator Online
  • Subscribe in Netvibes
  • Subscribe in Google
Using Gristmill
  • What is Gristmill?
  • Posting rules
The comments of Gristmill users reflect the opinions of those individuals only, and do not necessarily reflect the viewpoints of Grist, its staff, its board members, their psychotherapists, or their aestheticians. Got it?

Gristmill is powered by Scoop.

ADVERTISING POLICY


About Grist | Support Grist | Job Board | Archives | Grist by Email | RSS | Podcast
Gristmill Blog | In the News | Ask Umbra | Muckraker | Victual Reality | 'Tis the Season | The Grist List | The Bottom Line



Grist: Environmental News and Commentary
a beacon in the smog (tm) ©2008. Grist Magazine, Inc. All rights reserved. Gloom and doom with a sense of humor®.
Webmaster | Sitemap | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Trademarks