Staff Contributors
Guest Contributors

Smithfield hogs the China market

Looking at an industrial-meat giant's China deal

Posted by Tom Philpott at 9:07 AM on 18 Sep 2007

Read more about: China | food | agriculture | business | animal welfare

While PETA roils Gristmill and other greenie sites by brandishing climate change to promote vegetarianism, Smithfield Foods just keeps cranking out industrial meat.

As I noted in last week's Victual Reality, the company recently announced a deal to sell 60 million pounds of pork to China. Since then, Smithfield has revealed details about how it will fill that order: by ramping up production at a slaughter facility in Sioux City, Iowa, hometown of one of the nation's most ambitious local-food initiatives.

Reports Reuters:

The [Sioux City] plant will begin processing an additional 3,200 hogs a day next week, or about half of a normal production shift, [a Smithfield spokesperson] said. Also, the plant will add about 250 workers.

Wow -- an extra 3,200 hogs per day; just like that, as if it were no big deal. You don't have to be a PETA-style vegan to marvel at the carnage. Since I didn't get the chance to dig very deeply in to the China sale in Victual Reality, now's my chance.

One remarkable thing about the Smithfield-China deal is that it's rather small, by the standards of the world's largest hog producer and pork processor.

Sixty million pounds of pork? According to Motley Fool, Smithfield annually churns out some 3.1 billion pounds of "the other white meat" in fresh form -- and another 2.9 billion pounds of processed product (i.e., sausage, etc.).

However, Wall Street is betting that Smithfield's deal could be the start of a long and profitable relationship between the world's largest pork company and the world's most populous nation. That's why rumors of the China sale pushed Smithfield shares up 7 percent last month.

First of all, the China market is the great prize of hog producers. According to the USDA (PDF), China alone accounts for more than half of global pork consumption. Indeed, China as a whole consumes some six times more pork than the world's next-most ravenous pork-eating nation, our own United States.

And, as Lester Brown never tires of reminding us, Chinese demand for pork is rising. The above-linked USDA report shows Chinese pork consumption surging 22 percent between 2002 and 2006; U.S. consumption held steady over that period.

Meanwhile, China has tried to satisfy surging demand by employing the U.S. model: consolidating and industrializing meat production. As one hog-industry site puts it:

China's hog industry is "rapidly consolidating" on a scale similar to that in the U.S. ... This includes the segmentation of farrowing and finishing, with 500- to 1,000-head sow barns and "routine off-site finishing" popping up around Chinese cities.

However, this effort has hit a major wall: a massive disease outbreak. Chinese hog producers are discovering that confinement-style livestock production provides an ideal atmosphere for disease: stressed animals with weakened immune systems, conveniently packed together.

Evidently, a malady called blue-ear virus, first found in U.S. hog confinements in 1987, is raging through China's feedlots, mutating to forms unseen before. Chinese scientists are frantically searching for a vaccine. Like their U.S. counterparts, China's industrial hog growers are quickly finding that they need constant help from the pharmaceutical industry to keep their hogs alive until slaughter.

Last year, blue ear wiped out some one million hogs in China, and the government has not revealed the full extent of damage this year. However, pork prices in China are surging, which signals a serious ongoing problem.

So, you've got a nation with surging demand for pork, and a falling supply. That's where Smithfield comes in. In a conference call just before the China deal was finalized, Smithfield CEO Larry Pope titillated Wall Street analysts by speculating that Blue Ear could wipe out as much as 20 percent of Chinese hog production -- an amount roughly equal to total U.S. hog production.

If so, China represents a dramatic opportunity for U.S. companies like Smithfield. As one hog-industry observer put it, "If this scenario is true, the potential for further Chinese importation of pork is almost incomprehensible."

Even without blue ear, though, it looks like China and other "developing nations" are set to become more and more important target markets for U.S. industrial-food purveyors. The USDA recently released a major study called "Global Growth, Macroeconomic Change, and U.S. Agricultural Trade" (PDF, don't dare download it unless you're a real ag nerd), explaining why.

To summarize: Demand for food in the U.S. and Europe has essentially matured -- that is, it's growing at the same slow pace as population. In the "emerging market" nations of the global south, however, populations are rising more rapidly than in the post-industrial north, and in countries like China, Mexico, and India, a growing middle class is demanding more "high-value" food like meat.

"As a result," reports the USDA, "the share of U.S. [food] exports destined for emerging markets climbed from 30 percent during the early 1990s to 43 percent in 2006." Mexico and China have been particularly popular destinations of the fruits of the U.S. food industry: "These two countries now account for 25 percent of U.S. [food] exports -- nearly triple their share in 1990."

For this reason, I foresee U.S. industrial meat production raging ahead no matter how successful PETA and other campaigners are at goading U.S. consumers to shun meat.

And here we come to the limits of campaigns based on individual responsibility. The real way to take on the meat industry is to agitate for political reforms that force Smithfield and its few meatpacking peers to pay up for their environmental messes, treat their workers fairly, and stop torturing their animals as a matter of course.

As I argued in Victual Reality, without the ability to abuse people, the landscape, and animals with impunity, the meat giants would likely wither away.

Addendum: An interesting footnote about Smithfield's China deal. China would only agree to buy the pork if Smithfield would guarantee that it be free of ractopamine, an additive routinely found in U.S. hog rations.

I'm not sure why Chinese authorities strictly oppose ractopamine use; the U.S. hog industry loves it because it supersizes livestock, resulting in lots more lean, low-fat meat. (At risk of infuriating PETA types, I will add here that this obsession with lean meat, gained through careful genetics and additives like ractopamine, has utterly ruined the flavor and culinary value of conventional U.S. pork.)

Ractopamine also evidently brings misery to hogs. From a USDA report (hat tip to the blog What On Earth Are We Eating):

[Use of] ractopamine has been ... accompanied by ... reports of effects on the behavior of the pigs, making them "hyperactive" and more susceptible to transport stress ... At the end of the 4-week study, [ractopamine-treated pigs] had higher heart rates than control-fed pigs and higher levels of circulating stress hormones.

Prediction...

100 years from now when we look back and catalog the elements of most egregious environmental degradation of the 21st century industrial meat production and the ecocide taking place in the oceans will rank as #1 and #2.

Economic Illiteracy Harms The Planet! www.voicesofreason.info.
Here's extra good stuff we get from pig farms....

drug resistant bugs and bacteria from all of the anti-biotics:

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/09/18/opinion/18tue3.html

Economic Illiteracy Harms The Planet! www.voicesofreason.info.

antibiotics

I saw that NY Times editorial too, good for them. About time mainstream papers cover this aspect of factory farming that animal agri-business doesn't want us to know about. We all need to reduce our consumption of pork and other animal products, especially factory farmed. The more money animal agribusiness has, the easier it is for them to get away with practices like this.

twist the knife...

The Chesapeake Bay is all but dead.  Now Smithfield is twisting the blade.  A few million more pounds of hog manure will finish the job.  Keep eating your bacon, environmentalists...

Il faut cultiver notre jardin.
How to make people see...

I wish I knew what would kick people in the gut enough for them to say enough is enough.  My father was just in the hospital with blood clots in his leg and in his lungs.  He's overweight and has a terrible diet.  He's now on warfarin (which was originally manufactured as a rat poison), still has the clots, but the other day I found him eating a deep dish Canadian bacon pizza with a big glass of soda.  Personally, I think someone needs to jump down the throat of physicians, as well, for being so irresponsible as to prescribe people medicines without addressing dietary and lifestyle issues.  

Maybe if more doctors were scaring people with the realities of their fatty, meat-laden diets, more people would be eschewing meat.  I say physicians need to come out in force, too, and quit hiding behind their pharmaceutical reps.

You are not logged in. Thus, you cannot post a comment. If you have an account, log in. If you don't have an account, well, by all means go make one! Meet you back here in five.
sign in
Search Gristmill
Subscribe
  • subscribe via RSSStay updated with the Gristmill RSS feed.
  • Add to My Yahoo!
  • Subscribe with Bloglines
  • Subscribe in NewsGator Online
  • Subscribe in Netvibes
  • Subscribe in Google
Using Gristmill
  • What is Gristmill?
  • Posting rules
The comments of Gristmill users reflect the opinions of those individuals only, and do not necessarily reflect the viewpoints of Grist, its staff, its board members, their psychotherapists, or their aestheticians. Got it?

Gristmill is powered by Scoop.

ADVERTISING POLICY


About Grist | Support Grist | Job Board | Archives | Grist by Email | RSS | Podcast
Gristmill Blog | In the News | Ask Umbra | Muckraker | Victual Reality | 'Tis the Season | The Grist List | The Bottom Line



Grist: Environmental News and Commentary
a beacon in the smog (tm) ©2008. Grist Magazine, Inc. All rights reserved. Gloom and doom with a sense of humor®.
Webmaster | Sitemap | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Trademarks