Staff Contributors
Guest Contributors

Cloned meat: at what risk?

Also, ew

Posted by Samuel Fromartz (Guest Contributor) at 9:47 AM on 06 Feb 2007

Denise Caruso, author of Intervention: Confronting the Real Risks of Genetic Engineering and Life on a Biotech Planet, has an excellent op-ed that explains the deep concerns about animal cloning. If you have doubts about this issue, or want to be better informed, this piece is a good place to start.

She makes the point that the FDA has not assessed the real risks of these animals -- not enough is known about them. More importantly, the subject of the FDA risk assessment was extremely limited.

In the case of cloned meat and milk, for example, the FDA focused on nutritional and compositional equivalence, which means that according to its tests, the chemicals that make up the food appear to be "substantially equivalent" to those in traditional food. In the ordinary practice of science, this kind of intensely narrowed focus isn't a failing. Experiments have to be rigidly controlled so they consistently produce or cause the same result, over and over again.

But the results of these rigidly controlled experiments often lose their evidentiary power once a living biotech product is released into the real, uncontrolled circumstances of life outside the laboratory, where they grow and reproduce and where someone has to decide whether they're safe.

This is just a snippet, but in total, it's about the best piece I've seen questioning the safety of these animals.

Another Report on Cloning

Forgot to mention this.  Jim Riddle, former chair of the National Organic Standards Board, the citizens advisory panel to the USDA, wrote a highly detailed report on cloning as well: "Is FDA's Cloning Proposal Ready for Prime Time?"

Samuel Fromartz Author Organic Inc.
You are not logged in. Thus, you cannot post a comment. If you have an account, log in. If you don't have an account, well, by all means go make one! Meet you back here in five.
sign in
Search Gristmill
Subscribe
  • subscribe via RSSStay updated with the Gristmill RSS feed.
  • Add to My Yahoo!
  • Subscribe with Bloglines
  • Subscribe in NewsGator Online
  • Subscribe in Netvibes
  • Subscribe in Google
Using Gristmill
  • What is Gristmill?
  • Posting rules
The comments of Gristmill users reflect the opinions of those individuals only, and do not necessarily reflect the viewpoints of Grist, its staff, its board members, their psychotherapists, or their aestheticians. Got it?

Gristmill is powered by Scoop.

ADVERTISING POLICY


About Grist | Support Grist | Job Board | Archives | Grist by Email | RSS | Podcast
Gristmill Blog | In the News | Ask Umbra® | Muckraker | Victual Reality | 'Tis the Season | The Grist List | The Bottom Line



Grist: Environmental News and Commentary
a beacon in the smog (tm) ©2008. Grist Magazine, Inc. All rights reserved. Gloom and doom with a sense of humor®.
Webmaster | Sitemap | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Trademarks